Analysis: U.S. Energy Dominance To Face Supply Glut in 2026


   
Barani Krishnan
DTN Refined Fuels Market Reporter

   SECAUCUS, NJ (DTN) -- As 2025 draws to a close, the U.S. oil industry finds 
itself at a crossroads. The pursuit of energy dominance has successfully pushed 
domestic production to record highs. Yet, this milestone arrives just as a 
global supply surge -- led primarily by OPEC+ -- sends prices tumbling toward 
four-year lows.

   The result is a sector paradox where, despite solidifying its role as the 
world's leading producer, the U.S. is facing a price environment that tests the 
economic limits of the drillers who made it possible.

   While the revival of "Drill, Baby, Drill!" defined the domestic production 
landscape, analysts point out that the 20% drop in crude prices for 2025 is a 
global phenomenon driven largely by forces outside the Permian.

   Beginning in April, OPEC and its allies began unwinding production cuts to 
reclaim market share. As the pressure from tumbling crude prices became 
undeniable, the coalition announced in November a pause in all output 
increments for the first quarter of 2026. By then, the damage had been done.

   U.S. production hit 13.9 million bpd in November, stemmed from post-pandemic 
operational efficiencies and a consolidation in mergers and acquisitions (M&A) 
consolidation, rather than new regulatory tailwinds.

   According to recent Dallas Fed surveys, producers noted that while 
regulatory loosening under the Trump administration marginally lowered average 
break-even costs by about $1 bbl, the broader price decline is being dictated 
by international flows and a growing global glut.

   U.S. energy dominance has been supported by the explosive growth in crude 
exports, which are projected to end 2025 at an average of 4.5 million bpd, a 
9.8% year-over-year increase and an all-time high, says the Energy Information 
Administration (EIA).

   This surge is fundamentally shifting global trade flows, particularly into 
Europe, where U.S. cargoes are replacing sanctioned Russian oil barrels.

   The U.S. dominance extended to the natural gas sector, where LNG exports 
rose 25% this year to 14.9 Bcfd, according to EIA data. 

   Fueled by new terminals and bolstered by massive demand from AI data 
centers, domestic gas prices nearly doubled to a projected $4.20 MmBtu, EIA 
data showed. While the oil market struggles with a surplus, the 2026 gas market 
outlook shows tight supply conditions.

   Consolidation 

   The wave of 2024 M&A activity -- headlined by ExxonMobil's $64.5 billion 
acquisition of Pioneer and Chevron's $53 billion takeover of Hess -- created a 
super-major class capable of weathering lower prices.

   The math for the rest of the shale patch is increasingly difficult, as the 
Permian Basin requires roughly $61 per barrel for new drilling break-evens, 
while the Eagle Ford and Bakken plays generally require $70 bbl to justify new 
activity.

   With WTI hovering near $55 bbl, new drilling in these basins is effectively 
underwater for many mid-sized players, Phil Davis, energy trader at PSW 
Investments, said. "Producers will keep existing wells pumping because of sunk 
costs that had already been cleared," Davis said.

   The administration's impact on the market remains a double-edged sword. 
While trade tariffs have raised concerns over dampened global demand, efforts 
to replenish the Strategic Petroleum Reserve provided buyers for domestic 
crude. Sanctions on Russian, Venezuelan and Iranian oil trade have also created 
a mass shadow inventory that has added to the global glut.

   The current surplus, estimated at 2.3 million bpd by the International 
Energy Agency, has been forecast to reach 4 million bpd by 2026 -- a figure 
that would surpass pandemic-era oversupply levels.

    




(c) Copyright 2025 DTN, LLC. All rights reserved.